Not long ago, at a Vipassana meditation meeting I attended, a practitioner described to the group a conversation he’d had over dinner with a Zen adherent. As he explained, “We decided that to be a good Buddhist is to be a bad American. Because to be a good American is to be a consumer, while to be a good Buddhist is to see through that consumeristic mindset.” The other people at the sitting agreed or disagreed to various degrees. Their conversation brings up many good questions. Is there a conflict between Buddhist and American values? How are each of those defined? Can one be a good American without being a “consumer?” Can one be a consumer and still be a “good” Buddhist? Is this conflict inherent, or might it change in the future? Is there something about being American that conflicts with Buddhism, or might other countries/cultures experience similar conflicts? Of course, there’s no single answer to any of these questions. But please share your thoughts on the subject, if you wish.
Thank you for subscribing to Tricycle! As a nonprofit, we depend on readers like you to keep Buddhist teachings and practices widely available.