Between-States: Conversations About Bardo and Life
In Tibetan Buddhism, “bardo” is a between-state. The passage from death to rebirth is a bardo, as well as the journey from birth to death. The conversations in “Between-States” explore bardo concepts like acceptance, interconnectedness, and impermanence in relation to children and parents, marriage and friendship, and work and creativity, illuminating the possibilities for discovering new ways of seeing and finding lasting happiness as we travel through life.
***
At the beginning of Ocean Vuong’s latest novel, The Emperor of Gladness, 19-year-old Hai, a queer Vietnamese American grappling with addiction, stands on a bridge preparing to jump. Grazina, a Lithuanian immigrant with dementia and traumatic memories of war, persuades him to reconsider. They form an unlikely friendship, caring for each other in a world where just surviving day to day is a struggle. An exploration of displacement and intergenerational trauma, memory and immigrant identity, the novel illuminates the hardships of living in the margins, as well as the grace that can be found there. “My book is about being in bardo,” Vuong told me. “Everyone is in a liminal space.”
Born in 1988 in Saigon, Vuong came to the US with his family at the age of 2 and grew up in Hartford, Connecticut. His first novel, On Earth We’re Briefly Gorgeous (2019), spent six weeks on the New York Times best-seller list and has sold more than 2 million copies. He is the author of two collections of poetry, Time Is a Mother (2022) and Night Sky with Exit Wounds (2016), and his work has appeared in the Atlantic, Granta, Harper’s, and the New Yorker. His numerous awards and honors include a MacArthur Fellowship, the T.S. Eliot Prize, and the Whiting Award. Currently a Radcliffe Fellow at Harvard University, he teaches Modern Poetry and Poetics in the MFA Program at New York University.
Vuong spoke with me from his home in western Massachusetts about finding new possibilities in bardo, engaging with your true self, and why he looks forward to death.
*
In bardo, new insights and possibilities are available to us if we have the right perspective. Is this something you’ve experienced? One hundred percent. In bardo, we don’t have the grounding of the physical body, so our emotions and thoughts can be more chaotic. But the power of the bardo is that if we stay aware, we can see things in a new way.
It’s something I experienced with my mother. I took care of her for a long time, which was a kind of bodily experience because so many of my literary and career decisions were based on her material well-being. I was like, “How do I get my mother out of Section 8 housing? I need to become a professor, I need to write, I need to get a contract.” These were the things that were on my mind even though, like any young writer, I told myself, “Oh, innovation above all, forget about your career, blah blah blah.”
I didn’t know how much my anxiety was impacting me until my mother passed. Then, as she entered her bardo, I entered a creative one, where I was no longer tied to this obligation I put on myself to tend to her materially. After she was gone, I went through an intense, chaotic time, but I also thought, “Well, now that those bodily ties are cut, what happens? What can I be? What can I think?”
I didn’t know how much my anxiety was impacting me until my mother passed. Then, as she entered her bardo, I entered a creative one.
You’ve said that writing The Emperor of Gladness was a way out of the grief you felt after your mother’s death. What role, if any, did the idea of bardo play in that writing process? It’s such a great question. No one has asked yet about that. I used the whole novel, the writing of it, as a bardo, a liminal space of grieving, a place without landing. And the idea of bardo became fundamental to the story. You can even argue—I usually avoid telling this part because I’m not interested in explaining my books, but we’re talking about dharma, which has a different pressure for me—that there’s more than one possible understanding of what happens to Hai. One is that he jumps from the bridge, and the whole novel is his bardo hallucination before his death. Another is that he jumps, and the whole novel is his bardo hallucination in death, with the entire story taking place in the unconsciousness of the death state.
When I was writing the book, I also found that I wanted to really use Buddhist philosophy as a literary model. You expect canonical literary works to be models, and I have plenty of those, but I wanted to use Buddhist philosophy, including The Tibetan Book of the Dead, as a literary project as well.
Can you say a bit more about that? It’s so important to experience the canon as a made thing, to not get trapped by that curation and think those are all the books worth paying attention to. The Tibetan Book of the Dead is incredibly rich in imagery and metaphor. There’s so much poetry in it. I wanted to point to it as a book that one would put next to The Brothers Karamazov and The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn, as a way of saying, “These are the books that inspired my novel.”
A central idea in The Tibetan Book of the Dead is that we’re the artists of our lives, shaping our trajectory with the choices we make. This idea is evoked in your novel when you write about Hai not taking certain paths that are “invisible until he’s long past their junction.” Do you feel that you’ve missed paths? Oh, yeah. I think my missing paths was part of why I became an artist. I’m such a feeling person, and feeling and thinking are perhaps too present in my life, to the point where there have been times when a junction has come and I’ve failed to act, like with sexual awakening and understanding my queerness. There were so many opportunities when I was younger, with my friends and other people, and I never acted on them. I was too scared, or too much in the middle of processing it all.
The Tibetan Book of the Dead speaks to this, describing dazzling lights we see in bardo that are the lights of our true nature. We turn away from their radiant beauty, drawn instead to the dull lights of our habitual propensities, the things we do that aren’t aligned with who we are and make us unhappy. My work now is the psychic return to act things out on the page, to do the things I didn’t do. Things I should have said, conversations I should have had, things I should have done with family, with loved ones, as a teacher, all of it. The page becomes a way to recoup it and become who I always was.
Before I became a writer, the opportunities for the true self never arose, or if they did, were never rewarded. And so they were not sustainable. I can now participate in a truer self for longer periods, and what I’ve found is that when you engage with your true self, it’s not just this isolated, individual journey. When you engage with that light, other people see it. And they say, “Oh, what is that? How do you live this intellectual, emotionally rich life?” And I say, “Well, it wasn’t always there. I had to make room for it, just like anything else. I had to fight for it.”
When you engage with your true self, it’s not just this isolated, individual journey. When you engage with that light, other people see it.
Becoming our true self is very much a question of attention, where what we pay attention to, what we engage with, determines the nature of our reality. There’s a lot of talk these days about how distracted we all are. How easy is it for you to pay attention? My brain was formed in a different world, so it’s easier for me to not get distracted. My childhood was entirely analog. I remember what it was like to look at a tree or the sky for fifteen minutes. With nothing like an iPhone to lay your eyes on, your eyes search, they wander, they see things that otherwise go unnoticed.
The Emperor of Gladness opens with an extended description of the fictional town of East Gladness, and that kind of detailed description is present throughout the book. It feels like a call to pay attention to what otherwise might go unnoticed, both the physical place and the people who live there. The novel begins with seven pages of description. On one hand, a writing workshop instructor would say it’s a cardinal sin to start a book this way, like, are you kidding? But to invest in description and slow down linear progression is a way to upset or recalibrate value in the work. What you’re doing when you refuse or delay plot is saying, “Pay attention. This is important.” East Gladness is a place some novelists would pass by, some drivers would pass by. It’s a flyover town, which is a politically charged phrase because, of course, the people who live there don’t think they live in a flyover town.
The bardo teachings urge us to accept reality but not give up, which is what the characters in your novel do, or try to do. The book draws on your own experiences of poverty and discrimination and addiction—how accepting do you feel of whatever is happening in your life? I don’t know if you can say I’m good at acceptance, but I’ve just always had a predisposition to be fatalistic about things. Like, whatever happens is the present.
When I’m writing, I could be thinking, “Is there another version of this? Is there another story?” But I almost never think that. I just think that this is the inevitable result of my consciousness tending to these ideas and whatever comes out is like a volcano spewing magma.
To me, life is about waiting and watching where the magma cools. It’s like, “Oh, that’s where it ends, there was no other alternative.” I don’t say, “How do we reroute magma?” Instead, I think, “Once it cools, what can we do with it?” Sometimes it spills into the village. Sometimes it spills into the sea. I’m always living in the most fruitful site of action, which for me is in the aftermath, rather than in the attempt to control.
We often find it hard to be fatalistic about endings, especially our own. How do you feel about death? I’ve been a hardcore Buddhist since I was about 15. I thought I was prepared when my friends died. I thought I was prepared when my grandma died. I thought I was prepared when my uncle took his own life. But you’re never prepared. You can read all the books, you can have all the intellectual reasonings and justifications. But the words themselves become a hallucination because they’re still of this world. They’re still of the matrix of this body, of this realm. The veil is pierced only when we enter that final journey, which I look forward to.
You look forward to your own death? Yes, to learn. To see what it’s like, see if something will surprise me. I’m not in a hurry, though. I have a lot of work still to do here, and if I’m lucky, I’ll get to do it.
Thank you for subscribing to Tricycle! As a nonprofit, we depend on readers like you to keep Buddhist teachings and practices widely available.