The following article was written as a companion piece for Lewis Richmond’s upcoming Tricycle class, “A Buddhist Response to AI: Studying Samsara, Practicing Kindness.” Sign up today.
The Dalai Lama has often said that Buddhist practitioners should study samsara. Samsara means the everyday world of ignorance and delusion. His advice is foundational and practical; he is encouraging us to know the sea in which we swim. And because today’s technology is so inescapable and powerful, there is probably no greater magnifier of samsara today than technology, which now includes artificial intelligence. So, like it or not, we Buddhists need to deal with AI; at least we need to study it. As a lifelong Buddhist practitioner and teacher, as well as a former computer professional, I have my doubts as to whether AI is truly intelligent, but, regardless, its influence and power are sweeping the world, and, try as we might, none of us can avoid it. I am proposing that the practices and teachings of Buddhism can be a counterpoint to some of AI’s seductions and a protective shield from some of its dangers. But how, as Buddhists, can we accomplish that? What can we do?
Today, there is a near-war going on between two opposing camps: the realm of living things, and the realm of digital technology. The outcome of this conflict is likely to define every aspect of our long-term future—even whether we survive as a species at all. At least that’s what Nobel prize winner Dr. Geoffrey Hinton—known as the “father of AI”—has warned; other tech gurus have echoed his words. This is serious business. I have given names to these two camps: I call the world of technology “Byteworld,” and the world of living things “Lifeworld.” Byteworld and Lifeworld—these two are arm in arm, marching headlong into unknown territory. Of course Lifeworld (that is, ourselves) created all of Byteworld (as well as Buddhism), but Byteworld is breaking free of its human bonds and going its own way, like some golem-like clay doll magically come to life.
Computer technology arguably began with the invention of the mainframe computer in the 1950s, followed by the personal computer, the internet, smartphones, social media, and, finally, “artificial intelligence.” The biosphere, in contrast, has existed for untold millennia, evolving from single-celled organisms to dinosaurs, parrots, dolphins, elephants, the great apes, and us. Our human achievements are legion: fire, the wheel, great epics and dramas, symphonies and songs, towering cities and civilizations, sailing ships and rockets, myriad forms of civilization and social organization, religion and spiritual life, and, of course, Byteworld itself. Of these I think Lifeworld’s greatest accomplishment is religion and spiritual life—paths leading to inner transformation and an awakened state of compassionate awareness. Buddhism, which has been my life’s study, is such a path.
I know technology from the inside; beginning in 1994, for twenty-five years, I owned and managed a software company whose product was a business-to-business software application that I wrote myself. But before that I spent thousands of hours in meditation on my black cushion, as well as studying Buddhism with some of the best living teachers. So I’ve had a foot in both worlds. I know the thrill that comes from writing a block of computer code and watching it perform its magic in the real world. I also know how urgently our world needs the spiritual healing and compassionate perspective that paths such as Buddhism can provide.
Though I understand how Byteworld works, my refuge has always been the biological wisdom of Lifeworld. When I was younger, it was my hope that this coming age would be one of spiritual awakening, but, instead, I see all the attention, power, and money racing in the other direction: toward the godlike power of technology, a glittering secular deity whose silicon chips and farmland-destroying data centers are replicating like a metallic cancer. How can we rein in this explosive machine?
Technology and AI do have limits. I doubt that AI is on its way to being all-powerful, in spite of what some tech gurus say. These machines of our making emulate only some portion of what our brains can do—mostly their verbal and mathematical skills. There is so much more to the human psyche. Psychologist Howard Gardner has proposed a theory of eight forms of human intelligence. In addition to words and mathematics, he adds music (Mozart), spatial awareness (architects), physical ability (athletes and surgeons), naturalistic knowledge (gardeners), interpersonal intelligence (therapists, ministers, and mediators), and intrapersonal intelligence (the awareness of our inner states and processes). AI excels in words and numbers. But it lacks feeling and true emotion—the relational skills of which Gardner speaks—and an intimacy with the natural world of plants and animals. It’s worth mentioning that “intrapersonal intelligence” is also the domain of meditation, which involves paying attention to our inner physical and mental states. Intrapersonal intelligence, on which Buddhism is built, may be in time a hidden resource that could counterbalance the empires of Byteworld. If so, each of us as Buddhists may have a role to play.
AI offers power, wealth, and control to those few who create and deploy it, but its capacities are narrow compared to the biological wisdom that incorporates emotion, intuition, faith, and religion, the five physical senses, and our 64 trillion cells, each with its own DNA-powered intelligence that we share with the whole biosphere. AI is a kind of miracle, to be sure. There is no question that Byteworld has game, but Lifeworld has so much more. What AI entity could ever experience the grandeur of Beethoven’s musical heart? And, for that matter, what robot could pray?
I suspect that our fascination with the glories of AI will sour in time as its darker capabilities, including weaponization and environmental pollution, come to the fore. To summarize the core message of the Buddha’s path: Each of us is a living Buddha at heart, only waiting to emerge like a butterfly from a cocoon. We don’t need any additional machines or vast data centers in farmland or in space to achieve that. We already have what we need. We are the heirs of the whole biosphere’s intelligent rainforest. Awakening is a birthright for every one of us. Lifeworld offers us untold gifts, including the dharma. That said, the human realm is not an unalloyed good, and technology is not an unalloyed bad. Each domain is complex; each has its gifts as well as dangers.
Gifts and Dangers of Lifeworld
Living relationships. Everything in the world of the living is intrinsically related, but not by bits and bytes. We share with every living thing the pulse of aliveness; we share their DNA, their evolution and adaptability. In a more profound sense we share a living connection with all of reality. Vietnamese monk Thich Nhat Hanh calls this connectivity “interbeing,” and it is described in detail in Buddhist scriptures such as the Avatamsaka Sutra. Human community and family, the kind we can touch and feel in the presence of others, is foundational; in some ways it is our deepest intelligence. In Buddhism we call that sangha.
Slowness. Speed is our new god these days, but the pace of living things is of a different order. Lifeworld is optimized for survival and evolution. Lifeworld is actually neither slow nor fast; it simply marks the pace of being alive. A human baby takes nine months to gestate. It can’t be speeded up. A majestic redwood tree takes a hundred years to grow, or a thousand. It will never be digitized. The vibrancy of all living things, the unfolding of a whole human life from beginning to end, the blossoming of love and of family, each require their appropriate season and timing. Speed will not improve them. Deepfake emulation will not replace them. Life evolves and replicates in slow time.
Kindness. The world of the living tends toward kindness; kindness is an artifact of interbeing. Human beings can be cruel, too, but kindness is our higher goal. Digital intelligence can emulate kindness; already chatbots have been trained to tell us how good we look and how great our ideas are. But true kindness occurs through aliveness. It arises from the interpersonal intelligence that Howard Gardner describes, and it is intrinsic to sangha. The kindness we have can never be replaced by a machine. What is most true about kindness is that we need more of it.
Dangers of the human realm. Long ago the Buddha identified the dark side of the human psyche with his teaching of the “three unwholesome roots”—greed, aversion, and egoistic delusion. These “three poisons” have sullied and darkened every human generation, including ours. Just because we are Buddhas in the making doesn’t mean that we are blameless. Innately we are good, but that quality is too often clouded.
Dangers and Gifts of Byteworld
AI is not just chatbots. AI is rapidly being integrated in every aspect of human life. In business, AI is taking over marketing, customer service, and hiring; it is also now doing much entry-level computer programming. In banking, AI does fraud protection, lending, and customer service. Its military uses are rapidly increasing too. Candidly, AI is everywhere. These new AI roles present many dangers; here are just a few of them.
Addiction. Social media is already addictive, and harms children; AI is making it more so. Criminals using AI have discovered new ways to defraud, to steal, to harass, to invade privacy, to destroy reputations, even to kill. Terrorists may soon use AI to create a weaponized virus with no cure. Has all this AI-enhanced digital connectivity been worth it, just so we can ask our chatbot for the best recipe for banana bread?
Jobs. The fear that AI and humanoid robots driven by AI will replace jobs is everywhere. People say they are afraid for their livelihoods and their very future due to AI. The deeper issue is that for the most part the creators of AI and the politicians who make the rules don’t seem to care that much about people’s worries. Are we on the cusp of major social discontent, even disorder in the streets? AI riots?
Environmental Impact. In order to do its work, Byteworld requires huge data centers, many the size of fifteen football fields. They are sprouting up everywhere: in previously quiet suburbs; on farmland that once grew crops for food; on the edge of big cities where there is power and water to satisfy their cooling needs. There are already thousands of these centers supporting the digital “cloud”; it is estimated that in the next ten years, to support AI, 3,000 more of these monster construction projects will be built just in the US, with many more in other countries. Each of them requires vast amounts of water and electricity; many also have huge diesel- or gas-powered turbines that pollute the air. These centers are also noisy; those who live near them say that their sound is a loud sleep-disturbing hum. Some local governments are fighting back, but there are billions of dollars to be made by building out this AI infrastructure. When there is that kind of money to be made, ethics and care tend to go out the window.
Technology’s Gifts. To be fair, AI has also brought many new benefits. In the realm of medicine alone, AI is already contributing lifesaving technologies such as early cancer detection. It is speeding all manner of research and helps with weather prediction, eldercare, education, and so much more. These benefits are bound to expand with each passing year.
My Religion Is Kindness
The Dalai Lama has often said, “My religion is kindness.” Because this is such a simple statement, people may not realize how profound it is. He doesn’t only mean “Kindness is valuable and good.” He means that Buddhism as a wisdom practice transforms us into people who are unconditionally kind. The Buddhist term for that type of person is bodhisattva. Lifeworld is the crucible where this kind of compassion can be nurtured.
Once, when the Dalai Lama was asked if he was angry at the Chinese, he replied, “The Chinese have taken so much from us. I won’t let them take my state of mind.” Even in the face of that pain, he maintained his kind heart. I was, for a time, the personal attendant of renowned Vietnamese Buddhist monk Thich Nhat Hanh. He spoke softly and carefully, as though each word were a treasure. The sound of his voice itself, and the way he lifted the cup of tea I had poured for him, radiated kindness.
For my own teacher, Shunryu Suzuki Roshi, kindness was second nature. I witnessed, so many times, when he reached out to help someone or touch a person who needed his care. One time, I came to meditation early in the morning, and there, on the front steps, was Suzuki, quietly talking to a homeless man. As I stepped past them to enter the building, he didn’t look up. He was doing his work.
This unconditional kindness is, I think, the most precious thing in the world. I fear that the implacable march of technology will crush this treasure. I fear that Byteworld will toss it aside as unnecessary, seeing it as a weakness, dismissing it as unable to make money or wield power—an obsolete quality that human beings will no longer need.
I don’t want that to happen. I want kindness to survive, and not just to survive but to prosper. I want everyone to see through the false promise of a light speed digital future and remember what binds us together and connects us to all life—kindness. Without kindness, I fear, we will become wan and hollow. As the Dalai Lama has said, our religion as Buddhists is kindness. Kindness is the best of who we are. It is our not so invisible power.
Breathwalking with Byteworld
In the course of pondering Lifeworld and Byteworld, I have created a library of contemplative exercises to help us experience the difference between them. Here is one called “Breathwalking with Byteworld.” It uses a smartphone to illustrate how Byteworld takes us away from ourselves, and how we can return to ourselves by walking in awareness—a venerable Buddhist practice.
To begin, stand in a quiet uncrowded place—a hallway in your house or an unpopulated outdoor path—and lift up your smartphone. Open the phone’s camera app so that you can see the scene in front of you. To start, let the phone drop to your side and begin walking slowly, feet a shoulder-width apart, one step for each exhale, so that your whole body flows with movement and your mind observes it with attention and awareness. In ancient days, Buddhist monks would spend hours each day walking just like this on their verandas or in forests.
Now, lift up your phone and look at it. Watch the scene in your camera unfold while you continue to walk. Notice how the pixel version of what you are seeing gradually absorbs all your attention, while the awareness of your body slowly recedes. The scene you see is almost the same as without your phone, but it is an emulation, a deepfake, if you will. Everywhere, these days, we see people absorbed in that phone world—in airport lobbies, restaurants, classrooms, on sidewalks, even in a moving car—people glued to their phone, watching the alternate universe it presents. Have we all become phone zombies, walking around holding up these shiny rectangles in front of our faces? Sometimes it seems that way.
Now, shift gears again, let the hand that holds your phone drop down, and return to the awareness of breath and your body as you continue to walk. Feel the transition, the bump in the road as the familiar physical world returns and the emulated imagery of the phone screen goes away. The phone is more than a passive copycat. We know now that the apps, texts, photos, and videos on that phone can cause harm. They can hurt children. In the moving car of a distracted texting driver, they can kill. By practicing Breathwalking with Byteworld you can bring the awareness exercise of Buddhist practice to the fore and disempower this deceptive device.
More and more people are becoming aware of how technology is distorting their reality. There are now paid phone apps that lock your phone out for a time, forcing you to give it up when you lack the willpower to do it yourself. You can also go on vacation to an expensive resort that offers a phone-free environment; you give them your phone when you register. These remedies are salves and medicines; look for there to be more of them in the future.
Looking Ahead
It is hard to say what will happen with all this mad swirl of technological change. There are as many predictions as there are savants to utter them. The truth is no one knows. Meantime, to return to the question that began this essay, what should we as Buddhists do?
One possibility is to escape, to remove ourselves as much as possible from the influence of technology and AI. Buddhism’s monastic tradition seems to offer that option. Monastic life is one form of “living off the grid,” staying far from the buzz of the big city, in hidden valleys where everyone knows your name, where people have put away their phones, unplugged their devices from the internet while they tend their own vegetable gardens and write notes to each other in longhand simply because it is more beautiful.
But there is another option besides escape. To paraphrase Pope Leo, “We shouldn’t reject technology but prevent it from dominating humanity.” Buddhists can have a role in that. Bodhisattvas may train in the monastery, but they don’t stay there forever. The vow of the bodhisattva says, “However many beings there are in the world, I vow to liberate them, to care for them all, be kind to them all.” This vow is a commitment not to escape but to engage. As Buddhists we can study the samaras of technology to become more skillful at helping, even as we continue the transformative practices of studying ourselves. We can choose to live in the light of kind action. When there is an opportunity to help, we do not hesitate; when an opportunity doesn’t immediately present itself, we practice patience, tend to our practice and wait. That opportunity will come soon enough.
We can, each in our own way, become exemplars of a life that upholds the highest human values and the deepest inter- and intrapersonal human intelligence, even as AI and its manic golems sweep the world. The bodhisattva vow manifests an awareness and an intelligence that no machine or digital brain can match. We Buddhists dedicate our lives to it, and uphold it as long as we can until others rise to take our place. Even in the face of the loudest criers of technological doom—who may, in the end, be wrong—we keep confidence in that vow.
May it be so.
Thank you for subscribing to Tricycle! As a nonprofit, we depend on readers like you to keep Buddhist teachings and practices widely available.