ponlop rinpoche, tricycleOne year ago I wrote a post I called, “Is Buddhism a Religion? The Question that won’t go away.” I think it’s clear now that the question will come round again and again. Along with “religion vs. spirituality,” it seems to be a perennial favorite. Now, the esteemed Buddhist teacher Ponlop Rinpoche takes on the question in his recent Huffington Post column “Is Buddhism a Religion?” What he describes (as opposed to Stephen Batchelor’s “Buddhism without beliefs”) is a “Buddhism beyond religion.” Since I tend to think of Buddhism as religion, I was very interested in reading his post and found it useful. What’s not clear to me, though, is whether a “Buddhism beyond religion” would include rebirth, let alone reincarnation, and other elements based on belief rather than science. My impression from Ponlop Rinpoche’s post is that reincarnation isn’t a Buddhist sine qua non, but I can’t be sure. Bhikkhu Bodhi, among others, is clear that without a belief in rebirth, one cannot properly call oneself a Buddhist. I’m not so interested in defining who’s a Buddhist and who’s not, but I do think if we include in our worldview ideas like rebirth (or, in Tibetan Buddhism’s case, reincarnation), it would be difficult to argue that Buddhism is not a religion. Great post, I’d love to hear more.

Temple
Dharma to your inbox

Sign up for Tricycle’s newsletters

Thank you for subscribing to Tricycle! As a nonprofit, to keep Buddhist teachings and practices widely available.

Liberate this article!

You’ve read all three of your free articles for the month. Subscribe now for immediate access to the magazine plus films, video dharma talks, e-books, and more.

Subscribe Now

Already a subscriber? Log in.